© 2021 West Virginia Public Broadcasting
Telling West Virginia's Story
Play Live Radio
Next Up:
0:00
0:00
Available On Air Stations
Radio

Scared to Write a Note

450px-Ricky_Ian_Gordon_publicity_shot.jpg
Copyright owned by Kevin Doyle
/

Thumbing through a copy of Opera News, an article on opera composer Ricky Ian Gordon revealed some very provocative words:

"The twentieth century is littered with a lot of composers who were terrorized out of writing what they heard-out of writing in ...their authentic voice. There was such a critical backlash against...tonal music. I mean you could write...you were just laughed off the map."

What is music? Such a simple question. Such complication behind the answers.

The early 2oth century composers were in a real bind. Were they going to be followers of Serialism, Indeterminacy or Neoclassicism? Tonality, for all intents and purposes, was an anachronism-something so quaint that only the inferior or less serious composers would chose as a musical language.

(Think this attitude is gone? A few years ago, one of my colleagues made an off-hand remark about the 12 Tone System and a listener wrote that anyone with any knowledge knew that the last serious (read important) works were written in this style. So, we must remain in a prison based on a system that began in the 1920's?)

Or worst choice of all: write the music they heard in their own minds?

We all talk about the arts in terms of freedom, but there's always a quid pro quo. The questions become: why are we writing? Who are we writing for?

If there's a shadow hanging over your shoulder of what you "should" be writing or a host of critical voices in your mind, you're never going to write the music that is your true voice.

Mr. Gordon is writing no less than three operas. 

I doubt he has much time to listen to the voice of doubt or to the ghosts of musical eras past.


WVPB is local news, education, music, and entertainment for West Virginia.
Your donation today will help keep us strong and vital.