Opioid Antidote Can Save Lives, But Deciding When To Use It Can Be Challenging

Oct 29, 2018
Originally published on November 2, 2018 7:33 am

On a 90-degree afternoon in July, under the shade of a tree in Philadelphia's McPherson Square Park, I watched a couple sit down, prepare syringes and inject drugs.

The man injected in his arm, the woman in her neck.

I observed them from about a hundred feet away, where I was getting ready to film an interview with someone else.

After they had finished, the woman rested against the man. She was splayed out on top of the man with her neck tilted back, her mouth open.

The next time I glanced over, her skin looked pale. The man supported her head, rubbing her breastbone, and checked her pulse.

The city has cleaned up the park — which used to be known as "Needle Park" — and ramped up the police presence there. There was even a group of kids playing on a nearby Slip 'N Slide that day. But drug use remains commonplace in the park and in Kensington, the surrounding neighborhood.

The woman I was there to interview, Jasmine Johnson, is in recovery now. But she was in active addiction on the streets of Kensington for six years.

I looked to her face for cues, to see if my rising concern about the couple was warranted.

I had done enough reporting on overdoses that I thought I would know how to respond when I saw one. Plus, the city's health department makes it sound simple. In Pennsylvania, anyone can pick up naloxone (also known by the brand name Narcan) at a local pharmacy without a prescription.

Billboards in subway stations and along the highway advertise naloxone, the overdose-reversal drug: "Saving a life can be this easy."

But in the face of a possible emergency, it seemed more complicated to me.

Johnson, who carries naloxone in her purse, went over to check on the woman and offer her the antidote.

The man angrily refused it.

Johnson tapped the woman lightly on the cheek, to see if she would wake up. She didn't.

The man insisted again that she was fine. "She's breathing!" he yelled. He told Johnson he didn't need Narcan, and that he already had some. "Do not give her Narcan," he mumbled. "She would be so mad."

To understand why someone who uses drugs might not want naloxone during a suspected overdose, it helps to understand how the medicine works.

The antidote quickly blocks the effects of opioids — both the euphoria and dangerous side effects, such as slowed breathing that cuts off oxygen to the brain.

In the process, it can send someone into instant withdrawal. Many people who use drugs say withdrawal is like having the worst flu of your life, complete with cold sweats, shakes and vomiting.

The man likely didn't want the woman to suffer Narcan-induced withdrawal and end up mad at him.

While I knew all of this in theory, it hadn't registered with me until that moment that someone would risk death to avoid withdrawal.

As Johnson and I wrapped up our interview, the woman still looked pale and unconscious. I didn't know what to do, and Johnson could tell.

"That's all you can do, is ask and keep moving," she said with a shrug.

But was that really all we could do?

"It's not easy," said Allison Herens, the harm-reduction coordinator at Philadelphia's Public Health Department.

She conducts regular training sessions about naloxone and how to administer it. She started a recent session for about two dozen people at the South Philadelphia Library on Broad Street by describing naloxone as "as harmless as water."

But Herens said the overdose antidote can be a little tricky to use. "There are lots of different kinds of emergencies that happen on the street in any moment, and it can be hard to discern if it's actually an emergency or not," she told the group.

It's important to make sure someone is actually overdosing before giving naloxone, she said.

A person might be nodding out, coming in and out of consciousness. "The big thing to keep in mind with that person is, are they breathing?" she said. "How does their color look? So they'll start to get pale, gray – depending on the complexion, blue."

Now, with the increased presence of fentanyl in the drug supply, Herens said the signs of an overdose are even more varied. Fentanyl often causes muscle spasms, or locked jaws in addition to the traditional signs she described.

She also confirmed that sending a drug user into withdrawal is a real concern. "If they wake up in full-blown withdrawal, they are not going to the hospital. They just are not," Herens said. "They are going to go run as fast as they can to try to use again, and I know because I've seen it happen."

If you suspect someone is overdosing, call 911 right away, Herens said.

Jeremiah Laster, a deputy chief at the Philadelphia Fire Department, agreed. "Sometimes you have people that when you administer Narcan to them, they become combative because they're upset because you sort of blew their high," he said. "You have to be prepared to protect yourself."

There are other reasons to call for help. Narcan, a nasal spray, starts to wear off after about 30 minutes, and nearly dissipates after 90, depending on a person's metabolism and the strength of the drugs used.

By then, most people will probably have metabolized enough of the opioids so that they are unlikely to stop breathing again. But fentanyl, which is particularly potent, makes that less of a guarantee.

It can take multiple doses of Narcan to reverse a fentanyl overdose. And once you've given the nasal spray to someone who has stopped breathing, it helps if you perform rescue breathing to hasten the flow of oxygen to the brain.

For these reasons, Herens said it's important to know from the start that you have paramedics coming to help.

Ultimately on that day in McPherson Square Park, I called 911.

Once I did, another woman nearby told the woman who was passed out that the police were on their way with Narcan. Hearing this, the woman bolted straight upright and started to leave with the man. They got angry with the woman who told her the police were coming — there was some pushing and shoving — but soon all three were gone.

Herens estimates she has given Narcan about seven or eight times — mostly during a recent spike in overdoses this summer, not long after the day I was in the park.

She said she understands it can be hard to wrap your head around the fact that someone might get angry with you for trying to prevent them from dying of an overdose.

"I always just try to remember that in this moment I am saving this person's life," she said. "They don't have to like me."

Herens tries to keep it in perspective. Irritating people is a small price to pay if it means they survive, she said.

Nina Feldman covers health for WHYY. She's on Twitter: @ncannellf.

Copyright 2020 WHYY. To see more, visit WHYY.


More than 1,200 people in Philadelphia died of drug overdoses last year, the vast majority of them due to opioids. The department of public health there has a clear message to residents - carry naloxone. It's an overdose reversal drug that's easy to get. Allison Herens works for the city's public health department. It trains residents to get comfortable with administering the drug if they see a potential overdose.

ALLISON HERENS: We really say the naloxone is as harmless as water. You know, we really encourage you to give it, even if you don't know what the person took.

KING: Nina Feldman covers the opioid epidemic from member station WHYY and had a recent experience that made her question if it might be more complicated than that.

NINA FELDMAN, BYLINE: It was a really hot afternoon this past July, and I was in Philadelphia's Kensington neighborhood to interview Jasmine Johnson (ph) for a video project. Jasmine's in recovery now, but she lived on the streets of Kensington for six years.

I'm going to move you over a little bit.


FELDMAN: We met in McPherson Square Park, which used to be known as Needle Park. Since then the city's cleaned it up. When we got there, a group of preschool kids was playing on a Slip'n Slide on a nearby hill.

UNIDENTIFIED CHILDREN: (Playful laughter).

FELDMAN: But it's still a popular spot for people to use drugs. As we were setting up the camera, we saw a couple sit down maybe a hundred feet away and take out some syringes. We watched them inject - he in his arm, she in her neck. She leaned back onto him and relaxed, and we went on with our interview.

But after a while, the woman really wasn't looking so good. She was splayed out on top of the man, neck back, mouth open, skin pale. He was checking her pulse. Jasmine went over to see if the woman needed naloxone, also known by its brand name, Narcan. But the man she was with angrily refused it.

UNIDENTIFIED PERSON: No. She's not - she don't need Narcan, dude.



FELDMAN: Jasmine tried to wake the woman up. It didn't work. But still the man insisted she was fine.

UNIDENTIFIED PERSON: Yo. She's breathing.

FELDMAN: Jasmine came back over to where we were filming.

JOHNSON: He says she's fine. She's just really high. She's fine.

FELDMAN: She's breathing?

JOHNSON: Yup. And they're not just going to let you do it because she's like - she's going to be so mad.

FELDMAN: To understand why someone who uses drugs might not want Narcan during a suspected overdose, it's important to understand how the drug works. Narcan is usually given through a nasal spray, and it bumps the heroin or other opiates off the opioid receptors in the brain. That blocks the effects of the drugs - both the euphoria of the high and the slowed breathing that cuts off oxygen to the brain.

That's why Narcan saves lives. But in that process, it can also send someone into instant withdrawal. Many people say withdrawal is like having the worst flu of your life - cold sweats, shakes, vomiting. While I knew all this in theory, it just hadn't really registered to me until now that someone would risk death to avoid withdrawal. As Jasmine and I were getting ready to head out, the woman still looked pale and unconscious. I didn't feel right leaving, and Jasmine could tell.

JOHNSON: That's all you can do is ask and keep moving.

FELDMAN: But was that really all we could do? I just couldn't shake the feeling that the woman might've been overdosing while we just stood there watching.

HERENS: So how do you know when to do something?

FELDMAN: That's Allison Herens. She's the harm reduction coordinator at Philadelphia's public health department, and she's leading a training about naloxone. She's the one who said earlier that Narcan is as harmless as water. But even she admits it's tricky to know when to use it.

HERENS: You know, you see the person who is nodding out, but they'll come back to consciousness, right? But the big thing to keep in mind with that person is, are they breathing? How does their color look?

FELDMAN: Herens says if someone has stopped breathing, definitely give them Narcan. But because the effects of withdrawal are so bad, you really want to make sure that they need it.

HERENS: If they wake up in full-blown withdrawal, they are not going to the hospital. They just are not. They are going to go run as fast as they can to try to use again. And I know because I've seen it happen.

FELDMAN: Jeremiah Laster is a deputy chief at the Philadelphia Fire Department whose EMS workers administered Narcan more than 5,000 times last year. He says it is common for people to be upset when they come to. Because of this, Laster says there are some situations when it's probably better for a civilian to just stand back and wait for professionals to get there.

JEREMIAH LASTER: Certainly, if you had somebody that's, you know, 6-foot-4 and was, like, 300 pounds, you want to be very, very careful how you wake that person up. You have to be prepared to protect yourself.

FELDMAN: This advice seems to contradict the city's push for the public to carry Narcan, but Laster and Herens both say it's just about knowing what to expect. One thing everyone agrees on, the first thing to do is call 911. Ultimately, that's what we did.

As soon as the woman heard the police were coming with Narcan, she bolted straight upright. She and the man were angry. Their highs had been blown. They got up and left before the police arrived.

Herens, who estimates she's given Narcan about seven or eight times, says at the end of the day, someone being irritated is a small price to pay. For NPR News, I'm Nina Feldman in Philadelphia. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.